Thursday, September 24
Princeton, N.J.
We’re in the third week of the fall semester here, and I’m finally through my start-of-the-school-year jitters. (Regular-grade anxiety remains.) Official protocol and policy dictate that I not write about my students. But I don’t think I’m violating any rules by telling you that they’re thoughtful, creative, eager, and lovely.

The journalism program is unique on campus, I think, in that a significant part of the learning takes place one-on-one, akin to the Oxbridge tutorial system. We have one three-hour seminar as a group each week, but I also meet individually with each student at least six times during the semester. These sessions are scheduled for 30 minutes, but many have gone 45, even an hour. We might talk about their most recent writing assignment or their ideas for an upcoming one, how the semester is going or just life—often, all of the above.
When I’m sitting in these sessions, I sometimes feel as if some of my best teachers are hovering lovingly just over my shoulder. All of them did much more than impart knowledge. They fed me, which is not a metaphor: oatmeal cookies, which I’d never tasted before, in third grade; a lavish, end-of-semester buffet with steak and salmon my freshman year of college; smoked chicken at the end of grad school. Several bolstered my courage with their exhortations. Two forever changed the way I teach; because of one, I had the audacity to tell my students that I expect love to grow in our community of learning, and because of another, I’ve been sharing with the class what I’ve learned from them, reminding them that, while I might be their professor of record, they’re teaching me—and one another—too.
I don’t care if they see me as some unfashionably earnest weirdo. (I think the world could use more unfashionably earnest weirdos.) During our first class session a couple of weeks ago, I told my students that I care about their reporting and writing. But more than that, I care about them as humans—complex humans, humans with histories, humans who come carrying all the invisible baggage collected wherever they’ve been and whatever they’ve experienced.
That’s why I bring snacks to class each week; we all get hungry, and we all can feed others. That’s why we discussed the myth of objectivity and the importance of fairness. And that’s why I’ve been writing them little missives, which I post each week on our course website and which I hope will offer them some encouragement.
Maybe this week’s note to my students might offer you some encouragement too. It’s called “Apprehending the World.”

In 1975, the writer Joan Didion gave a commencement address at the University of California-Riverside. She talked about understanding the world—or, to be more precise, not misunderstanding the world:
I’ve had to struggle all my life against my own misapprehensions, my own false ideas, my own distorted perceptions. I’ve had to work very hard, make myself unhappy, give up ideas that made me comfortable, trying to apprehend social reality. I’ve spent my entire adult life, it seems to me, in a state of profound culture shock. I wish I were unique in this, but I’m not. You may not be afflicted with my misapprehensions, and I may not be afflicted with yours, but none of this starts “tabula rasa.” We all distort what we see. We all have to struggle to see what’s really going on.
Didion had by then already become a literary star and a practitioner of a kind of immersive creative nonfiction that came to be known as the New Journalism. She and other members of her cohort were open about their subjectivity, were unafraid to be present in the story, and blurred the lines between “literary” writing (whatever that is) and the stereotypically journalistic.
In her speech, Didion addressed this question of subjectivity and objectivity. She reported throughout the 1960s, a tumultuous time she described as “a period in which some people began to wonder if the symbols didn’t mean anything and you couldn’t trust the words; if there was any objective reality at all.” It’s one thing to say, as a human and as a writer, that objectivity is impossible—that’s on us and our limited capabilities—and altogether another to assert that objective reality itself doesn’t exist:
What you might be blinded for, what you ought to watch out for, is the habit of saying no, the habit of not believing anybody or anything. You’ve got to watch out for moving into a world where you don’t think there’s any objective reality, where there’s only you and that tree you just planted. There’s an objective reality, there is an objective social reality. Take it on faith. All I want to tell you today, really, is not to do that. Not to move into that world where you’re alone with yourself and your tree. I want to tell you to live in the messy world, throw yourself into the convulsion of the world.
Is it human nature to want order amidst the chaos? The creation myths of so many peoples talk about some higher power spinning something resembling wholeness out of disarray. Is it just how we are wired, to wish for dissonance to resolve into harmony? Certainly a mom of a stereotypically messy teenager with a stereotypically messy room might quibble. But, big picture, it’s not easy to live in the messy world, or to endure its convulsions.
Our own lives will have their own convulsions, too, and nobody should ever blame or shame you for getting motion sickness on this wild ride. Journalism, though, has at times provided its own comfort: Solidarity, perhaps, at the ubiquity of hardship as part of the human condition. Sometimes, to be honest, escapism—escape into another culture, escape into someone else’s story, escape into another’s troubles as a temporary distraction from one’s own.
Reared Episcopalian, Didion had by then become something of a fierce agnostic. Throughout her adult life, she eschewed any belief in gods, or higher powers, or the afterlife, of which she said once, “I don’t disbelieve; I just don’t believe.” At the same time, she did believe in some sort of order to life—“a larger pattern somewhere,” as she put it. Was this some version of existentialism? Secular humanism with a touch of... something else? Hard to say. I think one could make a solid case that she was a realist to her marrow, though:
I’m not telling you to make the world better, because I don’t think that progress is necessarily part of the package. I’m just telling you to live in it. Not just to endure it, not just to suffer it, not just to pass through it, but to live in it. To look at it. To try to get the picture. To live recklessly. To take chances. To make your own work and take pride in it. To seize the moment. And if you ask me why you should bother to do that, I could only tell you that the grave’s a fine and private place, but none I think do there embrace. Nor do they sing there, or write, or argue, or see the tidal bore on the Amazon, or touch their children. And that’s what there is to do and get it while you can and good luck at it.
Notice how relational life is through her eyes—connection with other humans, and the earth, and one’s adversaries, and one’s audiences. I don’t think it’s a mistake that the main verb she contrasts with the solitude of the grave is “embrace.”
You will define for yourselves why you bother to do anything, including this thing we are calling journalism. Seeing as I’ve already set any facade of objectivity aside, let me wholeheartedly and subjectively say that I do hope you will make the world better, not just through your writing but also through your being—being kind, being thoughtful, being neighborly, being gracious, being just, being wise, being curious, being complicated, being human.
I also hope you will take what Didion wrote to heart: Extend your embrace. It will be risky. It might sometimes hurt. But that is the good work—and, I’d even say, the good life.
You can read the entirety of Joan Didion’s commencement address here.
Several of you have written to ask for the syllabus. I’m not going to post it in its entirety (it contains a lot of arcane information, including grading rubrics and internal material). But I’ll post what we’re reading, along with links where I have them, so those of you who are interested can follow along.
One note: The course is “Reading and Writing About Religion,” not “Reading and Writing About Christianity,” and it’s a journalism class. My choices of reading material are intentionally wide-ranging but also exclude anything typically classified as “inspirational” or written for the devotees of a particular faith.
Before we even met in person, I asked the students to read the following:
“Americans Haven’t Found a Satisfying Alternative to Religion,” Lauren Jackson, The New York Times
“Losing Religion and Finding Ecstasy in Houston,” Jia Tolentino, The New Yorker (Sorry, I don’t have a gift link for this one or, indeed, any of the New Yorker pieces)
“The Religion No One Talks About,” Sarah Betancourt, Longreads
“Upon This Rock,” John Jeremiah Sullivan, GQ
All of these pieces have a first-person element to them, which, for a journalism class, might seem... odd? imbalanced? But here’s the thing: How do you write about other people’s belief (or non-belief) if you haven’t examined your own? So their first writing assignment was to pen a spiritual autobiography, an exercise that, I hoped, would compel them to consider their own biases, stories, and preconceived notions.
Week Two focused on reporting and writing about Christian nationalism, and it included pieces written from a variety of perspectives—first-person essay, immersive reporting, news analysis. What are the different angles from which a reporter can approach a subject? What responsibility does a writer have to disclose personal history? What distinct shapes can a story take?
Chapter 1 from Tim Alberta’s The Kingdom, the Power, and the Glory
“Confessions of a Former Christian Nationalist,” Rob Schenck, Mother Jones
“How Christian Is Christian Nationalism?” Kelefa Sanneh, The New Yorker
“Islamophobia’s Rise in Texas,” J. David Goodman, Lauren McGaughy, Jesus Jimenez, and Ruth Graham, The New York Times
“The Army of God Comes Out of the Shadows,” Stephanie McCrummen, The Atlantic “The New Faces of Christian Nationalism,” Rachel Monroe, The New Yorker
In Week Three, we concentrated on an international-reporting case study: the Buddhist-Muslim conflict in Myanmar. What do local eyes and knowledge bring to a story? How might an outsider perceive or frame things differently?
“Myanmar Burning,” Wa Lone, Kyaw Saw Oe, et al., Reuters
“The Face of Buddhist Terror,” Hannah Beech, Time
“What Happened to Myanmar’s Human-Rights Icon?” Hannah Beech, The New Yorker

More to come… In the meantime, I hope you will be surprised by delight and sideswiped by joy this week.
All my best,
Jeff


What this world needs is more "unfashionable earnest weirdos". Teach on!
What a treat to read ideas that you gave your eager students. I like to the idea of writing my own spiritual autobiography. What a place too to inspire creativity! Thanks for sharing some of Didion’s ideas that were new to me like no one should blame us for getting car sick on the wild ride!